I'd say 'Shutter Island', because it's directed by Martin Scorsese, and I know he did Taxi Driver which I've heard is a really phenomenal film.

I don't know much about 'The Crazies', except for the advertisements I've seen on television, I always thought it sounded liek a childrens' T.V. show though, I wonder why they chose such a silly title.

(And I'm quite annoyed at Burton's Alice in Wonderland for being unfaithful to the characters it's based on and literature it took it's name from, well, this is only second hand information, but from reliable sources!)