Cute Pumpkin

Jennifer - 1, 1b, 1c
Miriai - 1
Jaz - 1, 2
Ceridwen_Crystaline Ikoda - 1a, 1b, 1c, 1d
Knerd - 1

Scary Pumpkin

Jennifer - 1
FinnTheCat - 1, 1b, 1c
Majinkoz - 1, 1b, 2, 2b
Korrye - 1
Pyro neko Jess - 1, 1b
Yotsy - 1
BURN BISCUITS - 1, 1b

Scene or Non-Tradition 'Face'

Sphynxee - 1
La Tua Cantante - 1, 1b
Purdy Possum Pie - 1, 1b, 1c
Sphynxee - 1
Korrye - 1
Lilith W - 1, 1b
Burnt Biscuits - 1
Stormy1 - 1, 1b

Alternative
Ebuichan - 1
(note: this is a lil gourd and not a pumpkin so i've placed it under this category ^-^)