05-09-2008, 03:40 AM
There's good flow to the story, though it could easily be expanded upon. You might want to write some detail about how the room looks, feels, smells. And what about the lighting? Is it dark? Shadowy? Or bright? Even unpleasantly so? Is it damp in the cell? Does it smell of mildew? Things move along at a pretty good pace, but overall the story lacks sensory detail. If that was done intentionally, you should tell us why. Is your character blind? (S)he certainly isn't deaf, if she can hear the man speaking to her at the end.
You should also be realistic with how many days she's been there. 17 days is a very long time to go without food. Actually, it may be impossible. If I remember correctly, the human body can go for 40 days without water, but far fewer with no food. Is she being spoon-fed by a jailer? She can't possibly be eating prison food or catching rats for herself if she's chained and bound in a straight jacket. I think changing it to 7 would repair any research issues, and you can still say it feels like months to her, with no problem.
You should take care with word usage. Saying the girl's eyes were "dropping" doesn't make any sense. Where did they go? o.O You also describe the main character's face as "unreadable," but immediately afterward say her expression was "melancholy." Melancholy is a very intense emotion of sadness. There's nothing "unreadable" about it.
I thought your idea was pretty unique and engrossing; I definitely wanted to know what was happening to your main character, and if you write more, I would be interested to read it. But resorting to a cliché such as "silvery hair" totally kills off the originality. I would steer clear of stereotypically beautiful hair, such as black or silver, even if you're writing a fantasy story.
And one final grammatical note: "He said" is not a sentence. When you write dialogue, the person speaking and the way they speak should be together in a single sentence, not split into two. For example, you should say:
"I can't go out because I'm grounded," Eric said.
NOT
"I can't go out because I'm grounded." Eric said.
And finally, though I really like the name of your story, I don't see how "twilight" applies. The main character talked about not knowing what time of day it was, and about birds chirping. Birds chirp the most in the morning, basically, and without telling us how the lighting was in the room, there's no way we'd even consider thinking it was twilight.
I really enjoyed reading your work, and I definitely think you've got potential. Just try to be as realistic as you are creative, and things will come together nicely for you.
Last edited by Fin Raziel; 05-09-2008 at 03:47 AM..
|