Giving up on Project Mene? New Questions added 3/31!

[B][quote]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/B][/quote]
I don't think that you should close the contest for good. There has been a good deal of effort & time put into planning this contest and keeping it running. You shouldn't let your hard work go to waste. As for the blow up that happened in there earlier, it was just stupid. We shouldn't have let something like that get to us, and let it escalate out of control. Don't punish future contestants and those that were innocent for our idiocy. It's really a great contest, and aside from that - i did and still am having fun with it, and in retrospective that is what it's suppose to be about. In regards to your schooling and RL responsibilities; That i can definitely understand. But in my opinion, perhaps having a new host, or a few new hosts so they can share the responsibility would be more beneficial, or like you've suggested - Taking a small break.


[B][quote]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/B][/quote]
I think this is one of the better ideas. :)

[B][quote]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/B][/quote]
If you'd rather do that then pick a new host straight away then sure.


[B][quote]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/B][/quote]
It's entirely up to you - I'd love to continue to participate. And perhaps get a chance at judging myself. But i don't mind also that it may be on a break for some time.

[B][quote]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/B][/quote]
Well this is my first time, and so far i think your doing a relatively good job. Not sure on what you can do make it easier for you to manage. Seems to be well managed as it is. (Aside from the judges getting scores in on time) but that's to be understood with RL stuff going on. I've hosted many avatar contests and participated in many as well, so in terms of managing it - your doing an A+ job.

[B]
[quote]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/B][/quote]
I'd really rather you didn't do that. At least a few more though if you were [B]really[/B] sure you wanted to close it down for good.


[B][quote]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/B][/quote]
Picking a new host, i'm in favour for.


[B][quote]What would you look for in the new host? [/B][/quote]
Can afford to run the contest & be organized. A leader - someone who knows what they're doing and can take charge without hesitations or doubts. Is friendly & approachable.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
Sadpanda.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]
I'd prefer this as long as they ... er... were capable of being as fair and non-clique-y as you have been.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]
Yep.
[QUOTE]
For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/QUOTE]
I wouldn't mind that. I think you'd find interest would stay up if there were temporary host(s).

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
Perhaps have a minimum number of judge results in the time listed?
ie: You have four judges (five including yourself), but you only need to wait for 3 responses before going live with the results. That way if you're not feeling up to responding you don't have to. And if there's a judge or two who's having a busy/bad week, you don't have to wait on them either. But results wouldn't be posted until the date you set. (ex: You gave three days for judges to reply. Everyone replies early/on-time, so you post them all. But if you got down to the deadline for judges and hadn't got some, as long as you had three minimum judge scores, you could proceed).

It might be easier, in fact, to go with fewer "standard" judges and just ask people week to week if they'd be willing to judge. For example, all the contestants have turned in their entries and you PM two people to ask if they'd be willing to be a guest judge and if so, please reply with judge feedback. If they don't reply in time, no judge feedback.

Uhmm. Might also be easier to have an on-going sign-up for participating. Then you can just PM people right before the next season is going on to see if they're still interested.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]
::shrugs:: As many as the host can handle. I think it'd be easier and not harder to become more fair/objective the longer someone ran a contest like this. But when real life gets in the way, then it's real life that should win.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]
I would be very sad to see it go down for good. And while in an ideal world, you'd run it forever, I'd rather you picked someone you trusted to go with the original vision of the contest than forbid it ever be done again/see someone try to do it again and muck it up.

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host?[/QUOTE]
Someone fair.
Someone creative.
Someone who will take in fresh blood and not make PM into some sort of clique.
Someone who will try to select judges [I]and[/I] contestants with varying tastes, so that the results actually promote discussion on fashion/items/style/whatever rather than promoting standard "AC style" <-- which can be very interesting, don't get me wrong, but... There's a saturation point.
Someone who is drama-lite/free.
Someone who is fairly dependable. (They don't always have to do things right away, my concern is more with them suddenly getting bored and dropping it.)

Lotsa rambling, soz.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]

That really would be up to you. If you think that you wont want to host anymore, and dont think anyone else is up to hosting it, then that may be the best choice.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]

I think that if you could find someone that would be able to do as well as you in hosting, then that would be great. If not, then there isn't much you can do about it. It takes a lot of time and dedication to do something like this.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]

I would completely understand.

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/QUOTE]

Once again, if you could find someone suitable for it, then that'd be great.

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]

I honestly wouldn't know. I'm not sure exactly what process you use now, or what could be improved.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]

I think that you've done a good job at keeping up with it like you have and have stayed with it a long time. I think that any amount of rounds to host is a job well done.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]

I think it would be nice that this do stay alive and not dissapear forever. Even if it takes awhile to get picked back up.

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host?[/QUOTE]

Someone that is committed and has the time, and is good at picking themes.

++What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?

Noo. D: Project Mene's been going on since forever, please don't close it. D:

++What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?

SUPER LIKE. It doesn't matter if it takes forever, just don't close it. D:

++Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?

Yessss, that's totally fine with me. It's your contest now after all, so do what you please. And I understand how hard balancing school and other things can get, so take all the time you need. :]

++For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?

If you want to, then yes. :] Personally, I'd love to see Project Mene keep going and going, but if you don't want a temporary host and all the potential problems associated with it, then that's fine too. :]

++What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?

I don't know enough about the process to suggest anything. x-x

++How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?

I don't think there should be some sort of minimum. It's what you do for fun, not as a task or chore.


++Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?

New host. I know there's a lot of people who would be sad to see Project Mene go.

++What would you look for in the new host?
Someone who's creative, has decent avatar abilities, and has time for it.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]

I would of course be rather sad if this where to happen. Project Mene has been my home on Mene for a very long time (pretty much since I started on mene) and to lose that would make me sad, in the end though it is your choice.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?
[/QUOTE]
This is a better idea then completely closeing the place, as long as you can find someone fair and creative.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]
Absolutely, without a doubt if you are burned out from project mene or you need time for college (waaaay more important then Project mene no matter what anyone says xP)

For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?
[QUOTE]It might not be a bad idea. I think you may lose alot of the interest you worked so hard to gain if there where to be a break from the competitions. [/QUOTE]

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
I actually was thinking about this maybe you should create a Project mene Mule account that a few trusted people know the password to. That way if you have a particularly rough week you can just pop in and ask one of them to update and collect scores.

I also second CK's idea about going on with just a majority of the judges if one of them is having a bad week.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE] However many the host feels up to or capable of.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]

Again I say, this would be a sad day for alot of us, I think there are a few people who could do well in your stead. Maybe consider having it run by a small group rather then one person may create less stress.

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host? [/QUOTE]

Someone creative and fair. Someone who can stick with it through the entire cycle. Someone who can create largely creative ideas based around a theme, but at the same time someone who can stand back and be objective, and who picks people who are not totally one sided. They also need to have the time, this is important.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
Please don't. :< It's such a big contest, much bigger than other avatar contests out there, and there are a lot of people who have been waiting a long time to join, but maybe were to afraid to join previous cycles? It is a really fun thing, and has brought so many people together. I wouldn't want to see something so great end so abruptly.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]
I think it's better than any alternative. xP

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?
[/QUOTE]
Of course! Whatever you need to do. :hug:

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?
[/QUOTE]
I'm sure there'd be someone who would love to be a temporary host, so it couldn't hurt. Plus, then if you decide you're too busy you've got someone lined up (unless they don't want to host again, but meh)!

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?
[/QUOTE]
I can't really think of anything helpful. It seems pretty efficient as is, besides people being late... maybe you could have someone else choose the judges and participants for you? Or maybe have challenges only be every other week?

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?
[/QUOTE]
However many you feel like, really. Three was good for Donna, but it's not the same for everyone. I don't think there should be a set limit (well, more than one, maybe. xD)

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?
[/QUOTE]
Pick a new host! ;_; I would be so sad if you closed it for good.

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host?[/QUOTE]
Someone responsible and devoted. I think they should be intelligent as well and have the qualities of a good judge (good at making avatars and critiquing them, etc). Also, I think they should be good at wording things. That would make turning people away, making announcements, thinking up challenges and setting up the thread a lot easier. One question, though, would you want the new host to set up a new thread or use the old one? If it's a new thread, could the new host re-use the layout of the old thread and the FAQ/rules?

[QUOTE=bri]Someone responsible and devoted. I think they should be intelligent as well and have the qualities of a good judge (good at making avatars and critiquing them, etc). Also, I think they should be good at wording things. That would make turning people away, making announcements and setting up the thread a lot easier. One question, though, would you want the new host to set up a new thread or use the old one? If it's a new thread, could the new host re-use the layout of the old thread and the FAQ/rules?[/QUOTE]If I chose a new host, they would definitely have to create a new thread as I wouldn't be giving out my account information to anyone just so that they could continue on in hosting the contest in my absence or when I quit. And in regards to the re-using of a layout, that would be a no. When I took over the contest for Donna, I thought that it would be okay for me to reuse what she already had as she was really just transferring ownership, but I got a warning out of it because I failed to quote previously written materials, even though I had permission from Donna. The site has very strict policies set in place to prevent users from abusing the gold system, and though I personally wouldn't have any problem with a new host taking what I've already done to use when they set up a new thread, it would still be against site rules. And that's a shame, because honestly, I wouldn't want for someone to have to completely rewrite everything just because its against site rules for them to copy/paste. Exceptions aren't made fairly on this site for things like that, at least as far as I can tell from experience. I think that after a year and a half, and six successful cycles down the line, I still wouldn't be able to get that infraction removed from my account and anyone who tried to use what I have even with my permission would really just see the same fate and I don't want that to happen.

[COLOR="Indigo"]Oh, I see. That makes a lot of sense, actually. It really would suck to have to re-write all of that, dang. I guess that would be a sign that the new host is really committed, though. :/[/COLOR]

[quote]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/quote]
I would honestly hate for this to happen. :'< This contest holds a special place in my Mene life. It gave me an opportunity to improve on my avatar-making skills, and I would love it if at least one person can improve on their own skills just like what happened to me. =) Call me selfish, but that's my honest opinion. ^^;;
Also, I'm noticing that we're getting a lot of new blood in the AC now. It would be shame if the new people in the AC can't experience this. :x

[quote]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/quote]
I think this would be the best compromise I can think of. :3 A new host will allow you to rest, and keep the contest alive. Of course, a LOT of thought has to be put in choosing a new host, but I believe it's possible. =) <3<3

[quote]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/quote]
That seems perfectly reasonable to me. :3 You're not entitled to continue PM in the first place. And we all agree that RL comes first, right? I'm sure that others will agree. =) <3<3

[quote]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option? [/quote]
It depends on how long you plan to be gone, I think. If it's only for a few months, I don't think it's needed. We can always use a break from PM, right? But, if maybe you're gonna take at least 6 months to a year away, perhaps looking into someone willing to host for a bit would be a good option. =)

[quote]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/quote]
Maybe you can give more time for judging and avatar making? Sure, this will make the contest stretch out longer, but at least you won't have to think about PM every weekend and get stressed about it during the days when you actually have a break. ^^;;

[quote]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/quote]
Umm... it really depends on the person, so I wouldn't know. :'< Maybe... one host per year? >.<;;

[quote]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea? [/quote]
New host! D: As long as said host is someone you trust and is reliable, of course. I don't want PM's good name going down the drain now. ^^;;

[quote]What would you look for in the new host?[/quote]
Preferably someone who at least goes on Mene for an hour a day? Someone who's able to read through posts if needed. Someone who has time to dedicate to updating regularly. Someone who's also patient as well. And, preferably someone with "experience" on Mene, in reference to prize/s and knowledge on the rules and whatnot. =) <3<3

[quote]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/quote] Bad :ninja:

[quote]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/quote] I'd prefer it, definitely!

[quote]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/quote] Seiki-poo, you gotta do what you gotta do. Don't let Mene get in the way of that :yes:

[quote]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/quote] If that's what you want to do, I'd certainly enjoy it. It's a fun contest and there's not many as big as PM to fill the hole it would create in AC xD

[quote]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/quote] Eh, I really couldn't say. After running the Parody contest, I'd have to say that -most- (but not all) of my problems are the contestants. Unfortunately, you can't really get rid of those xD

You seem fairly organized on your end, so I don't think there's much else you could do, except make a mule to run it and share the mule with someone else.

[quote]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/quote] As many as you feel like ;)

[quote]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/quote] I like the idea of a new host, but only if that host is as good as you. I don't want someone utterly incompetent to pick up your spot, but then again, I doubt you'd pick someone like that anyway.

[quote]What would you look for in the new host?[/quote] Organized, organized, organized! x_x

And not afraid to be mean when called for. Preferably not a current staff member either, since their time tends to get eaten up. Someone who could also pass the baton when their time is up as well.

[B][SIZE="1"][COLOR="DarkRed"][QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]

Nuuu~ D:
The contest has been going on for so long, and it'd be a shame to shut it down when so many people scramble to join in on the fun, every cycle. xD

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]

Much better attitude. :'D
Choosing a new host after you decide to leave PM would be a much better decision, rather than just outright shutting it down.

It might take some time to find a new host, who has the time and passion to run the contest, but it's be worth it.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]

I think a lot of people would start to get a little impatient, as shown from your absence during the arts challenge. But, if you need time to think about it, I'm sure members would understand and wait for you.

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option? [/QUOTE]

If you could find someone who'll host temporarily without getting too attached, for when you return, then yes. I think that would be a great solution.

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]

I'm not sure hw wto word this correctly, actually. But I'll try. (Damn flu. :cry:)

If you could organize a team of people that didn't exactly want to participate in the actual contests, then perhaps they could help you come up with ideas, keep tabs on the thread, etc?

It's a weird idea, but I'm thinking of the system they used to use for UP, since some of the members couldn't always get online.

One flaw to this, would be that should they ever choose to leave the team, you'd be stranded again, and have to suddenly spend more time keeping things together.

But anyways, I hope that made sense. OTL

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]

Depends on how much effort went into the cycle, know what I mean? Take this cycle for example.

The Renaissance would take more planning and research, as to what the challenges were going to be, as compared to a cycle about toys, etc.

Once again, this might make very little sense. xD
Simple answer - Maybe 2-4 cycles? 3 would be ideal, I think.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]

Pickanewhost. ;w; <3
It'd be a shame to shut down this contest, as I said before, since so many people love it, and would probably spark complaints if you chose to shut it down. D:

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host? [/QUOTE]

Someone who really has a passion for the avatars and the contestants/judges.

Someone who isn't biased about whether the member is new/old, and they'd probably have to understand that AC'ing a perfectly matched avatar doesn't always mean it's the best. xD

But I suppose they could just choose judges that have the AC/Imagination elements in their outfit preferences.

I could probably think of more, but I'm hungry and my head hurts. Dx[/COLOR][/SIZE][/B]

[quote]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/quote]I think it would be sad to see it closed for good, but if you need to, I don't think you should burden yourself with something. It could end up with you being really unhappy.

[quote]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/quote]
I prefer this to it being permanently closed, as long as it's a good host and someone you trust to do the job well.

[quote]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/quote]
Do what you need to, man. I know you've been waiting to go to school for a while now and I think it's great that you finally have the chance. Your life is more important and I'll be cheering for you all the way :)

[quote]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/quote]
As previously stated, if there is a temporary host, I think it should be someone you fully trust and who you know can handle things. If Project Mene is going to suffer with a new host, I say just wait it out until you see what you can/can't do.

[quote]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/quote]Try out longer deadlines, maybe a co-host with a bit more time that maybe won't necessarily "take over" but still able to manage the basics. Perhaps PM needs a mule.

[quote]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/quote]As many as you can do without burning yourself out; if you're feeling tired then it's a good indication that you should at the very least take a break.

[quote]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/quote]It would be sad if this closed for good but I assume someone would eventually do something similar regardless. If so, it should at least be someone we all trust and I think you'd be able to pick someone that would do a good job.

[quote]What would you look for in the new host? [/quote]
I'd appreciate someone who's dedicated, creative, fair, and open to people's different ways of communicating ideas, while still understanding that there are objectives to be met as far as making an outfit goes.

Whatever happens, I wish you luck, man. I'm glad you're going to school after having to wait. Wish you the best <3

[quote]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/quote]
DON'T. If you no longer want to host, I understand that [i]completely[/i] and don't fault you in the slightest, but find a suitable replacement, don't kill it.
Project Mene has been a fantastic thing. It's helped people make friends, hone their avatar-making skills, come out of their shells, get out of ruts, etc. Don't kill it.
[quote]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/quote]
If you no longer feel up to the task, absolutely do it. But please use discretion. I don't want to see PM handed off to someone with the attention span and maturity of a fly who will run it into the ground. I wouldn't recommend holding open applications for the new host. Pick someone who you [i]know[/i] has the chops to handle it and ask them privately.
[quote]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/quote]
I see no problem with that, but then again, I'm not actively participating at this point in time.
[quote]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/quote]
That sounds like a good idea. But like I said above, use strict discretion when choosing your temp. host.
[quote]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/quote]
No longer be a judge. Just one less thing you have to do, then. Having been a judge before, I know writing up the judgments can be a bit of an undertaking. Even if it doesn't actually take that long, it takes quite a bit of mental energy - something you apparently don't have tons of at the moment.
Maybe appoint a trusted person as a co-host. You'd discuss the rounds with them beforehand, and they could stick around to answer all the questions ("are we allowed to..." "Can I use..."). The cohost could do even more (collect entries and judging scores) on weeks where you were particularly busy.
[quote]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/quote]
I really have no clue, it depends on the person. If you feel you're done, then you're done, Seiki. You've done more than enough, and no one would fault you for bowing out if life is getting to hectic. Don't sweat it. :hug:
[quote]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/quote]
I think I've already made my opinions on this clear, but please pick a new host who is suitable. Again, UTMOST DISCRETION. :lol:
[quote]What would you look for in the new host?[/quote]
Maturity, responsibility, organization, dedication to Menewsha and the community, being already quite familiar with PM and its workings, creativity, and did I mention maturity? Maturity. I would not recommend handing this off to a child or anyone who acts as one. I trust you not to pick a moron, but the nonetheless, I must say this. :lol: I'd be crushed to see PM go to unable hands.

[quote] If I were to choose a new/temp host, would any of you be willing to host it in my absense? [/quote] If I weren't in college also, I think it would be kind of a fun experience, but I don't have any experience as a judge so... I think it would be fun but I wouldn't be able to for a few reasons.

[quote]How would you take on a new cycle? What would you do for a theme/prize/changes?[/quote]I'm not sure if I should answer this one either since I'm not on enough to be "rich" but I think it should be a good amount of gold/something relatively rare since some might spend quite a bit during the contest and getting some of it back could be rewarding. Sorry about the run-ons >_>. Too lazy to fix :'<

[quote]What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/quote] I would like that. I can only enter cycles if they're during the summer, but being able to occasionally enter small contests would be fun.

[quote]Project Mene Mule - This will be a ways off if I decide to keep going with the contest a while longer, but as of right now a PM mule is not in the works. I do agree that in the long run, it would be more appropriate that a mule be created, but as I already have two mules (my own personal mule, and a mule for the iClone event), it is up to the new host who will take over after I do to get permission from a staff member to create or buy a mule account to use for this thread. Is that reasonable?[/quote]
Yeah, I think it's fair. Since the contest isn't moving for a while a mule right now would only be a pain.

[quote]Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.[/quote] I like the original material and don't think it should have to be changed. I think the first infraction you got was unfair seeing as you had permission to use the material in the first place v.v..

[quote]Do you guys think that I should make any changes to the contest as a whole, in regards to rules or challenges, or just how it's run to make it better?[/quote] I like how it's run. I haven't really been active enough to see what people are having trouble with, so in that regard, I'm not really sure I can say much.

[quote]Are there any rules that you currently disagree with?[/quote]I've always thought the rules were fair and challenging enough to make the contest an actual contest and challenge.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
Nuuu! That would be so sad. This contest teached me a lot, and it has still special vibe around it, being around for so long. I want everyone to be able experience it!

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest? [/QUOTE]
Well, that's up to you... if you feel comfortable leaving it in someone else's hands, you should do it! It will bring you a bit of rest.
[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both? [/QUOTE]
Of course, it's your life

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
Take more time between each rounds? Or maybe someone to assist you, take over judging/hosting some challenges? I think the idea of a co-host is good, it will make writing challenges easier, you guys can switch off hosting rounds/cycles.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it? [/QUOTE]
No Idea, maybe a couple of cycles (2 - 3?)
[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]
I would love to see it being continued *nods*
[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host? [/QUOTE]
Devotion.
I mean, one thing you can say about yourself Seiki, is that you were devoted to this contest and put a lot of effort in creating challenges, making sure judges send in their scores, etc. The new host should show that same attitude, even if he or she will only host a couple of rounds or cycles.

[FONT="Century Gothic"][COLOR="Purple"][QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
That would be a loss to the community, since this seems to be a popular contest.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]
By all means, if that's how you feel, it's your choice to make. I like how you run this contest, but it's a volunteer effort, and if you feel that it's no longer a commitment you want to make, that's your call. A new host to continue running this program for Menewsha would be a good idea.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]
Definitely. I don't feel like this has to be a continuous process, and I wouldn't see it to be a problem if there is a month or two between each cycle. Again, this is a volunteer effort on your part, so the amount of time you choose to dedicate to it and when you choose to do is entirely yours to decide. It has been generous of you to do so throughout the last six cycles, and no one has any right to demand more of you.

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/QUOTE]
Considering the popularity of this contest and the number of people who wish to participate, I believe that might be the best option, yes.

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
Have you considered co-hosting with someone? If you divide up the responsibilities of being the host, you'll only have half the work it entails each. The challenge, of course, then becomes finding someone you can work effectively with. Personally, if you need someone to help you with it on busier weeks, I'd be happy to volunteer, but you sure won't see me volunteering to take over completely even if I met all the requirements.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]
Again, this is a volunteer effort. The only person who can make that decision is the host. Just as Donna found three cycles to be as far as she could take it and you are starting to tire after six, someone else might lose interest after four or ten. I don't think there's a reasonable number of cycles that applies to everyone.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]
I am convinced that closing the contest for good would make a lot of people very sad, so yes, you should probably pick a new host.

[QUOTE]What would you look for in the new host?[/QUOTE]
I haven't been in this contest for very long, and from my experience thus far, I like the way you run it just fine, so maybe the question is what would YOU look for in a new host? In many ways, this is your pet project now, so you would know it better than anyone else, and your vision for it is just as important as everyone else's, if not more.

[QUOTE]As has been suggested, a new/temporary host has been in high demand rather than my permanent closing of the contest. If I were to choose a new/temp host, would any of you be willing to host it in my absence? Requirements would be that you've been a judge and a contestant so that you understand both sides, are able to come up with new challenges and cycle themes, have at least 5-10 hours a week to dedicate to PM, are able to come up with an adequate prize for the cycle, can enforce rules and deadlines, etc.[/QUOTE]
The only requirement I have yet to meet is having been a judge. However, even if I did meet all the requirements, I would still have to respectfully decline because it is a time commitment I am unable to make. Sometimes, I have trouble finding 5-10 hours a week to dedicate to eating regular meals, much less Project Mene. However, if the new host needs help with acquiring prizes, I would be willing to help with that.

[QUOTE]In regards to if I were to choose a temp host while I took a break, how trustworthy are you? I don't want to have to create a new thread just because I'm taking a break off for a cycle and I want to know that I can trust whomever I pick with my account information so they can update in my absence.[/QUOTE]
Again, if I had the time, I'd say you could trust me 100%. I don't do stupid shit, and I wouldn't steal pixels. I mean, they're pixels. Awesome pixels, but still PIXELS. I don't get people who hack into other people's accounts to steal virtual gold and items. It's not even real. =_="

[QUOTE]How would you take on a new cycle? What would you do for a theme/prize/changes?[/QUOTE]
I don't think this question is applicable to me, so I'll pass.

[QUOTE]What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/QUOTE]
Sure, why not? I don't see how this relates to the continued longevity of Project Mene, but it's not a bad idea by any measure, so if people want it, sounds good to me. You'd still have the prize dilemma though, so that might need more thought.

[QUOTE]Project Mene Mule - This will be a ways off if I decide to keep going with the contest a while longer, but as of right now a PM mule is not in the works. I do agree that in the long run, it would be more appropriate that a mule be created, but as I already have two mules (my own personal mule, and a mule for the iClone event), it is up to the new host who will take over after I do to get permission from a staff member to create or buy a mule account to use for this thread. Is that reasonable?[/QUOTE]
Yes, sounds reasonable to me, especially if the new host doesn't intend to remain the host for very long. I don't believe s/he will have a problem with getting the staff's permission for a Project Mene mule, and I certainly think that it would be the new host's responsibility.

[QUOTE]Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.[/QUOTE]
I think rewriting everything is a whole lot of unnecessary work if people are happy with what has already been written. By all means, look into getting permission for the reproduction of your materials.

[QUOTE]Do you guys think that I should make any changes to the contest as a whole, in regards to rules or challenges, or just how it's run to make it better?[/QUOTE]
If I had one gripe, it would be that the datelines are a bit too short. A few more days to make an entry would be good for people, especially when they're as busy as I am. I can't be the only person that does student government, helps run support groups and works part-time on top of classes. Most people I know do more than that, and real life due dates (should) always trump datelines for events like Project Mene. Thus, if we make each round slightly longer, you might have fewer people dropping out due to unforeseen circumstances like we had in this cycle.

[QUOTE]Are there any rules that you currently disagree with?[/QUOTE]
Nope, I think they're fine as they are, aside from the above little spiel on the timeline.

Ultimately, what you decide to do with Project Mene is entirely up to you, Seiki. Thank you so much for everything you've done. No matter what you decide to do about this program, I want you to know that your efforts so far will always be remembered and appreciated. Best of luck with everything in real life, and I hope you find a great new host if that's what you eventually choose to do. :heart:[/COLOR][/FONT]

[QUOTE]If I were to choose a new/temp host, would any of you be willing to host it in my absense? [/QUOTE]
I'd be willing when I have the time... So I would have to have a cycle that ended before September. I doubt I'll have much extra time from September to maybe this time next year. D: And September as a month is right-out. A friend will be visiting most of that month plus Halloween event plans during the time I do have online. :x

Genuinely, I want to help and have the personal funds and interest for it. But I would really only have the time for a [i]temporary[/i] hosting. IE: One season. Two at most. I wouldn't want to give any other impression. :x (And would of course not be upset if you thought someone else suited better. xD )

[QUOTE]In regards to if I were to choose a temp host while I took a break, how trustworthy are you? I don't want to have to create a new thread just because I'm taking a break off for a cycle and I want to know that I can trust whomever I pick with my account information so they can update in my absense.[/QUOTE]
Completely [I]un[/I]! 8D But the upshot of having a staff member fill in for you is they can just edit the posts without being in your account at all.

[QUOTE]How would you take on a new cycle? What would you do for a theme/prize/changes?[/QUOTE]
I don't see any reason for changes. ::shrug:: Prizes... I dunno. I have things laying around. I'd figure something out/I can give you a list of things I'd be willing to use as prizes and you could choose what you thought was appropriate.
As for theme... I might go through old Project Runway challenges and see what might suit PM with some tweaking. Like, "Make an outfit using food-related items. Must seem High Fashion." <-- poor example.

[QUOTE]What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/QUOTE]
Sounds good. Might be easier for you to handle if you want to keep your hand in and don't want to pass off your details to another user. :x
[QUOTE]
Project Mene Mule -[...] Is that reasonable?[/QUOTE]
Yup.
[QUOTE]
Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.[/QUOTE]
It'd be just as simple as quoting the original stuff and pasting it into the new thread, then sending you the gold from the mule to your main to make up for the gold you lost for quoting it. xD; <-- my personal take on it and unofficial.

[QUOTE]Do you guys think that I should make any changes to the contest as a whole, in regards to rules or challenges, or just how it's run to make it better?

Are there any rules that you currently disagree with?[/quote]
Can't think of anything right now. :x

Alrighty, I'll answer these questions for you too ^.^

[QUOTE]
As has been suggested, a new/temporary host has been in high demand rather than my permanent closing of the contest. If I were to choose a new/temp host, would any of you be willing to host it in my absense? Requirements would be that you've been a judge and a contestant so that you understand both sides, are able to come up with new challenges and cycle themes, have at least 5-10 hours a week to dedicate to PM, are able to come up with an adequate prize for the cycle, can enforce rules and deadlines, etc.[/QUOTE]

I actually was thinking about that a bit. Wondering between people who I thought would be the best person and wondering if I would take the job if you offered it to me. I went back and forth ALOT on this. I think if you where to offer it to me I would take the job, I also think there are others who would do just as well.

[QUOTE]In regards to if I were to choose a temp host while I took a break, how trustworthy are you? I don't want to have to create a new thread just because I'm taking a break off for a cycle and I want to know that I can trust whomever I pick with my account information so they can update in my absense.[/QUOTE]

I dont think the issues you should have over me should be trust. I try to be an extremely honest person.

[QUOTE]
How would you take on a new cycle? What would you do for a theme/prize/changes?[/QUOTE]

As for the theme, I'd have to think about this one, but I'll get back to you on that. The prize would be whatever I could manage to get my hands on, though I'd be sure to make it equal to the amount of work being put in by the contestants.

[QUOTE]
What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/QUOTE]

I actually really like this idea. Its a good alternative to completely closing for a shot time. As long as it doesn't completely become this.
[QUOTE]
Project Mene Mule - This will be a ways off if I decide to keep going with the contest a while longer, but as of right now a PM mule is not in the works. I do agree that in the long run, it would be more appropriate that a mule be created, but as I already have two mules (my own personal mule, and a mule for the iClone event), it is up to the new host who will take over after I do to get permission from a staff member to create or buy a mule account to use for this thread. Is that reasonable?[/QUOTE]

Of course it is.
[QUOTE]
Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.[/QUOTE]

I personally dont think its broken at the moment, so then why fix it. I dont really think the issues going on are the fault of the rules, but more the fault of people involved and their lives.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
I would hate to see this happen, as I was mainly a Cycle Spectator, and saw the contestants grow immensely during the PM process. This also is a place where people make avatars on guidelines, and go outside their comfort zone, which any artist needs to do sometimes in order to grow.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]
I would like you to if you have to leave for your own personal sake. It would keep a fun contest going, but it'd be a little bit different without you, however.

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]
Whatever you need to do is fine with me. I'd rather have no PM for a few months, and have a dedicated host, than a host who is stressed with balancing virtual games with school.

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/QUOTE]
I don't think so. If it's during an existing cycle especially, it can throw things off.

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
Maybe you could simply judge as the entries come in. So instead of it being __ entries at once, it can be possibly even 1-2 entries to judge a day, making it easier.

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]
That one is a toughie. I would probably say about 5+ cycles, spread out so that if something happens in that gap, you can not feel bad for getting away.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea?[/QUOTE]
I'd pick a new host, as the legacy would live on.
[QUOTE]
What would you look for in the new host? [/QUOTE]
Someone who is good with deadlines, very scheduled, creative, non-biased, good with people, and someone who is serious so that you can learn from them, and not silly all the time.
[QUOTE]
How would you take on a new cycle? What would you do for a theme/prize/changes?[/QUOTE]
For a new cycle, I'd take on a World History Timeline theme. Starting from the cave era, and ending in the far future era. As for prizes, I'd give the winner a set of each of the CI's that this specific cycle has been going on (so if it starts in April, and ends in July, I'd give the winner April-July CI's). For changes, I can't think of any at the top of my head.

[QUOTE]What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/QUOTE]
GENIUS!

[QUOTE]Project Mene Mule - This will be a ways off if I decide to keep going with the contest a while longer, but as of right now a PM mule is not in the works. I do agree that in the long run, it would be more appropriate that a mule be created, but as I already have two mules (my own personal mule, and a mule for the iClone event), it is up to the new host who will take over after I do to get permission from a staff member to create or buy a mule account to use for this thread. Is that reasonable?
[/QUOTE]I think a mule would be good ONLY if you chose 2 people for host. Otherwise it just gets confusing.

[QUOTE]Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.
[/QUOTE] I think the host should keep the rules, but just word it in their own words a little bit, so rewrite it.
[QUOTE]
Do you guys think that I should make any changes to the contest as a whole, in regards to rules or challenges, or just how it's run to make it better?[/QUOTE] I like how it's run currently, but I would like to see a partner cycle perhaps, where two people are paired up, as a team, and have to make two avatars, one per person, and assure cohesiveness.

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me closing the contest for good?[/QUOTE]
WHAT?! :gonk: But I never got to play! Don't!

[QUOTE]What is your opinion on me choosing a new host for the contest?[/QUOTE]
I don't mind, I kinda of though maybe you should have a training cycle with the next host, or have you thought of a co-host?

[QUOTE]Would you guys be okay with it if I chose to take a few months off from hosting the contest for my first semester of school until I can figure out if I'm able to continue both?[/QUOTE]
It's your life! You can't ask us how you can live it! *lolz* But really... I'd be sad. I realize I have never joined yet, but I was waiting till I was more prepaired! <3 It was my dream to join at some point!

[QUOTE]For the above question, should there be a temporary host if I choose that option?[/QUOTE]
I'd be okay with another host.

[QUOTE]What do you think would help make the contest easier for me to manage it in the long run?[/QUOTE]
I think a co-host option would be good, share the duties of it. Or how about you be the President host and they can be the vice-president host. That way you are still in CHARGE!

[QUOTE]How many cycles do you think is a reasonable amount to host before retiring from it?[/QUOTE]
I don't think there should be a quota at all! It's a personal choice I think. If you can do it, why not continue.

[QUOTE]Would you rather that I just closed the contest for good and not let it be picked up by someone else if I chose to quit, or would picking a new host be a good idea? [/QUOTE]
I personally would REALLY like if you chose a new host.

[QUOTE]
What would you look for in the new host?[/QUOTE]
Creativity. Fairness.
Honestly, I don't need a fancy prize ~ The idea of winning seems crazy enough for me, so - that's not really an issue for me... but like I said I would like the person to be creative and LITERATE! I don't want any "R U Cr8zy?"
______

[QUOTE]If I were to choose a new/temp host, would any of you be willing to host it in my absense?[/QUOTE]
No, I wanted to join the contest! *lol*

[QUOTE]What would you guys say to mini-contests in between cycles? A free-for-all so that everyone can enter for a chance at a prize, just like a regular avatar contest?[/QUOTE]
I would be excited about this! <3

[QUOTE]Project Mene Mule - Is that reasonable?[/QUOTE]
Sure! Why not?!

[QUOTE]Would you guys like to see the mule be allowed to use my pre-existing written materials for the new thread, or should anything be rewritten? I need to know so that I can get permission from an AA to copy/paste without any consequences.[/QUOTE]
Yes actually. Should I sign a petition?

[QUOTE]Do you guys think that I should make any changes to the contest as a whole, in regards to rules or challenges, or just how it's run to make it better?[/QUOTE]
At the moment I can't think of any.

[QUOTE]Are there any rules that you currently disagree with?[/QUOTE]
Again, I can't think of of any.