WYSIWYG?
 

It's... it's not working for me. On Chrome, it doesn't work at all, and on Firefox, if I press ctrl+u, for example, it'll add the coding around it, but that's it.
Didn't there used to be an option to switch to and from the wysiwyg setting? I can't find it at all.

It's under Edit options in your userCP :yes:

Are you talking about thing under 'Miscellaneous Options?' ^^;
I have it set to 'Enhanced Interface - Full WYSIWYG Editing.'

That's the only option for formatting choices. I can't really help with WYSIWTG because I don't use it, I hate it xD