Personally, I think the mustache doesn't look right.

D'awwwww ok. -goes to change it-
I wouldn't change a thing. I like the color scheme and everything!

I can't help but feel there should be a bit more yellow up top because you have subtle hints of it throughout the avvie but it's then this big thing of red up tom. Maybe try yellow eyes? Just a suggestion! You look cool :D

I think it's perfect. The balance of colours is awesome, and it tells a wonderful story. ^.^ Dont change a thing.

lose the fish

Don't change a thing. You look awesome.

Looks good~ No need to change anything. :)

Looks really good. I wouldn't change a thing (:

Dont chane a thing=)

I Would personally change the hair to have some darker highlights and possibly add at least one yellow thing but that's just me. >.> Overall I do like it though, it's quite unique!

I honestly love it how it is, the coloring is spread out nicely and what not (:

Maybe some yellow more spread out, but at the same time, I love what you have.

Don't change a thing! Your avatar is gorgeous!

You look like a delicious cupcake! DON'T CHANGE A THING!

Hm. You could use a hat or a hairclip. Or both. But I think I'd remove the cookie and the wand. They don't really fit.

Dont change a thing

add: yellow cutie shoes and something yellow for your head too... the yellow candy hairpin. so it looks like it got stuck in your hair. :)

Don't change anything; the colors are awesome!

Hmmm....can't think of anything to add or take off so I say leave it as it is :D

Don't ever change... I mean... what?

Hm. The hair color is a tad distracting, I think.

I love your look, don't change a thing!

Maybe put some red on your head? And perhaps also take off the black gloves and put on some purple ones?

Don't change a thing. You look awesome.

dont change a thing