Menewsha Avatar Community

Menewsha Avatar Community (https://www.menewsha.com/forum/index.php)
-   Archive (https://www.menewsha.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=124)
-   -   ROLEPLAYERS GIVE ME YOUR FEEDBACK (https://www.menewsha.com/forum/showthread.php?t=165798)

Light[xero]kn!ght 07-19-2010 12:05 AM

Actually I would like the 18+ section although you don't get any gold for posting, it would give freedoms to those who want to have explicit roleplays. Of course it would also be a good idea to put up a block for those under 18 years old.

It would also be a nice idea to have the picture of the character along with the post. Of course you should make it so that the picture doesn't interfere with gaining gold.

Soryko 07-19-2010 12:11 AM

The only other site I have ever really rolplayed on was Gaia. xD I'd say they are pretty similar...
You know how in the art shop forums, they have an option for you to set it to 'open, full, etc.' ?
It would be cool if the Rp forum had that as well.

I personally wouldn't use the 18+ area...I'm not sure how well that would work. o__O I mean, how could you confirm someone was 18? Just because they set their account to that age, it doesn't make it true. Or would it matter if they were actually 18...? xD I'm not really sure how that all works.

I'm not sure what you could possibly do that would require mennies...

Oh, what I liked about Gaia, was their suboforums for roleplay. Mene has a few, but I think it could use some more.

Sinsue Hoshigo 07-19-2010 12:34 AM

Ow! Yeah this is definitely a good idea! Yeah it is a pain though me and Siki (HI SIKI!!!) had to take our RP to yahoo and she saved each post... Though we had a few people reading our RP so they were a bit disappointed... As for the no gold thing... I guess I'd have to live with it... So if we had the thread *the pg 13 thread* in the normal 1x1's could we put a link for the 18+ thread on the first post?

x_cannibalisticcows 07-19-2010 01:16 AM

I role play to let my creative side free, and I use Mene as one of my outlets because I like the idea of literacy this site promotes.

I would defiantly be interested in an 18+ role play section. From some of the posts I've seen some people are limiting this restriction to smut scenes, but there are some other things that fall under the PG-13 rating that us role players wouldn't be able to do. Swearing, mature content, serious or offensive themes, violence/gore. All those rated 18A movies aren't just sex people. :]

I agree with the idea that the ability to delete posts would be very helpful. I for one also like to decorate my posts in a role play. I feel it helps bring the character to the stage more so being allowed to have pictures, quotes, song lyrics, etc... in my posts without the ugly quote tag around them would be very helpful!

Sorry, role play wise there isn't anything that would make me use my cash. I do it because I like it, and I can't see any features I'd be willing to pay for. [Though, a great way to appeal to the role playing group [fan based that is], is have series based items. [?]

Insomniac 07-19-2010 01:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flish (Post 1767857611)
As for improvements... Perhaps an 18+ forum with its own secret mods? Cuz if there's no gold on a forum, he'll just do IM roleplays if it's 18+ *nod* That could just be him though. Perhaps a way to automatically find roleplays by a certain person? Some people like stalking. XD

OH! And before Kinny forgets... an easier way to get to bookmarks? D8> At this point, it's easier to just leave every thread Kinny is active in open. XD;

Flish: You can stalk RP's by going here Menewsha Avatar Community - Search Forums and then selecting the RP forum and select a username. Not too hard ;)

Have you used thread subscription? That's a pretty easy way to keep track/bookmark threads.

Marguerite Blakeney 07-19-2010 01:55 AM

I like to roleplay because it gives me something to actually do on this site. I don't have normal conversations in the hangout thread as much because I'm totally antisocial. However, when I RP, I can be a totally different person other than myself. Other players and I get to connect on similar interests, which is great, especially for fandom RPs. I've also been roleplaying since I was 11 or 12 years old, so it's a part of me. Menewsha's my main choice of roleplay forum because I no longer visit Neopets and the RPs I'm "active" in on Gaia are dead. Also, RPing is my main source of "income" on this site.

My thoughts on the PG-13 restriction are that it's good so that everyone can participate. Sometimes scenes get really heated so we have to break them up before anything crucial happens. It's fine because I don't do that thing often. If there were an 18+ section, maybe that would be nice, but as we have 13+ year olds here (sometimes younger if members are lying about their age) there has to be a system blocker thingy implemented to restrict them from entering the 18+ section. It would be interesting to have one but what happens to the RPs that build up from PG13 to 18+ and then down? Would they take the scene to the 18+ area for the moment and come back? It would seem as if there was a basic 18+ board, the entire thing would be racy, but at least it would weed out the individuals who are underaged and keeps the more mature RPers in.

I don't have any suggestions to improve the roleplaying forum, though I would really appreciate an 18+ board to prevent minors from posting in. Also, I don't buy mennies so I have nothing to contribute on that front.

Chikuma 07-19-2010 02:15 AM

Quote:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
I roleplay because it's a fun and interactive way to be creative. Honestly Menewsha was the first place I ever RPed in a forum and is the main site I RP on. I RP on Mene because the site is more community based and it's got some really great people here. Plus I like how response the staff is. I know double posting isn't much of an issue anymore but before the spiffy new thing was put into place it was nice to know you could get a hold of someone to take care of those little mistakes.

Quote:

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
I would very much want and enjoy an 18+ section even if I didn't earn gold. I know most people are thinking of sexual situations but having an 18+ section would be great for those really gory and harsh characters and scenes you can't really dive into on the PG-13 restriction. I can think of a few characters I have created that I had to end up putting a curb on because they were a little to aggressive and/or abrasive. Having a 18+ section we would have a lot more freedom. I know most people are saying they would only use it for when scenes got to hot and heavy for the regular RP but I think it could be something a lot of us could use for entire RPs. War RPs, Yaoi/Yuri, and many fan based RPs as well.

Quote:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
Well adding the dice roll ability was great. I am really happy about that. I know a lot of folks want to be able to plaster images in their RPs but that drives me nuts. Maybe instead being able to set a simple 100x100 pixel as a header or footer for each post wouldn't be bad. It could be the image for each character without having huge images everywhere. To me the whole point of having a forum RP is to write the story not post images but I can understand wanting a better way then just colors to show who is talking.

Quote:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
Specifically for roleplayers? Not really.

Quote:

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?
Not much to add since the only other site I RP at offers less than you do. They don't have ads either though which is nice.

Orial 07-19-2010 02:20 AM

The reason i Roleplay is because it's pretty much the only thing i do on sites like this. I could care less about the events and what not. the only draw back is the fact that no one seems to be interested in my games, which is a big draw back and makes me wish to leave.

I'd LOVE an 18 and over area. infact i'd love it if we could PM serious stuff, because the current rules make PM's seem like they shouldn't even exist.

There's nothing that would make me spend money on this site. i'm sorry it's too expensive to buy mennies for rather uninspired items.

Flish 07-19-2010 02:21 AM

Insomniac: I have, but it's not as easy on other sites... it's hard for me to see the little tiny text menu under my account to get to it. :< He has a blurry screen so there be difficulty seeing. :<

Also, Kinny forgot about the search thing. XD; He's dumb like that sometimes.

FidelisRaor 07-19-2010 02:23 AM

I choose to RP here because it's literate. People actually care about character development and writing out what their character is doing.
I enjoy the PG-13 restriction because I don't really like ERP nor do I want to read it, so I like the fact that if you want to you can choose to take it to PMs.
As for why I roleplay...I'm an English major. I don't need a reason, but if I had to pick one I would say the feedback you can get. It combines the sort of 'what happens next' of reading with the character portion of writing.

beautiful_psycho 07-19-2010 02:27 AM

I defenetly agree with Orial on the mennies isue.

And as for the 18+ thing, it sounds good to me, im not 18 yet but it seems like a good idea for others to enjoy and I would like to use it when i come of age.

On the pg-13 rule...well it would be wey less stresfull not having to worry if y poast is R ratted or not. :D

I also think it would be a good idea to add some more catigories for the threds. And as a personal opinion I think posting should be rewarded more generously. :D
It would make it easier for buying stuff.

Salvaria 07-19-2010 02:31 AM

I really like Mene as a site for roleplay, and I think the thread options are well-rounded. I second the need of a delete post button, though.

I understand the need for money from this site, Inso. However, to charge for anything this site currently offers for RPing would be a big no-no.

I don't like the idea of an 18+ section, for that's what PMs and IMs are for, and I wouldn't like this to be the site people come to to cyber. However, as a happy medium, people that feel the need for 18+ threads should have to pay some Mennies for them.

I really like RPing because I love reading. I would like to write a story or something, but I'm not that skilled. Having another person to be a character makes RPing interesting, because they stick to the character's personality, and they don't always do what you want to.

Kia_ 07-19-2010 02:31 AM

Quote:

Hey everyone,

Looking at the stats it seems like over 10% of the site is made up of roleplayers. The current 'features' for you guys seem to be limited to the dice and having this here forum. I know roleplaying doesn't involve a lot of feature usage, but the space definitely has room for improvement. So if you have a moment, I'd love to hear any feedback you can give on the following:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?

Thanks guys!
Why I rp: I rp because it's fun and gives me something to do.

Why I choose menewsha for this: Because not only do you get to rp and chat about other things, open your own shops and charities and contests and make new friends and have fun and such. BUT you also get to create your avatar with unlimited amount of styles that you yourself can come up with.

I think the PG-13 thing is good so it makes it so no one has to worry about reading hentai or get too involved in the rp.
Also if there was an 18+ that would check out who was or wasn't 18+ for a rp like that, I would totally use this site waaaaay more often and would type in it even if I didn't get gold.

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better: I am not too sure on this part, maybe (just an idea) since most the time my pc has problems it likes to shut the net off on me and I lose whatever progress was made no matter the length and can't get it back. Maybe a small way to save it like a draft in that rp but on the user's account where they could go to retrieve it and then go back to it.

Or maybe also soemthing called script rp? Script rp is where the person...
Quote:

Ex: Sue: Hey lilly what's up?
Sue looked at her best friend and noticed she had dyed her hair a light pink and white.
Lilly: Do you like it?
(Please don't get mad at me for typing like this, it was just an example)

I always got in trouble for rping like that and I thought it was silly since it would go along with rping. There are deffiantly other ways to rp but that way is just seemed to be more fun I think. Anyways I think maybe in the rp forum, a section like that or something to where as long as it's not random stuff that it should be fine or maybe have a certain set of rules to where the people can rp but have to be checked by someone of the staff on here first to make sure they qualify.

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for: Hm...*thinks* Well maybe if we pay for mennies, getting a button with a mennie on it or something like that, something that would catch someone's attention.

Quote:

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?
I only like to rp on sites that have avatars or another fun way to rp. Besides the add thing, which I usually ignore there isn't much to add to this since MYFConline.com is my only other small rp site, you guys so far are my fav and I rp alot on other sites too in the past. I don't care for Gaia so this coming from me is a compliment that I like you guys waaay better.

Saravi Boo 07-19-2010 02:48 AM

Quote:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
I roleplay to relax and be creative while getting some social interaction. I do so on Mene because I feel welcome here and I like the small town feel of the site. I've made good friends here.

Quote:

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
Personally, no. If I want to do any X-rated roleplaying, I will take that up with my husband. ^_^ I do think that feature could draw some people to the site. *shrugs* I wouldn't be bothered if something like that was added.

Quote:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
I'm a fairly low tech roleplayer. I do wish there was a way for the DM or storyteller in an RP (the RP creator in other words) to edit within the thread. It would help to be able to correct spelling and grammar in literate RPs, to allow easy prevention of godmoding, and things like that. Things the mods don't deal with because they aren't against Mene's rules. I also understand if such a thing is not possible due to coding issues that I don't even pretend to understand. *shrugs*

Quote:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
Besides avatar items...no.

Quote:

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?
I don't RP on other sites. Mene is the place for me.

emiko_firecaster 07-19-2010 02:55 AM

Quote:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
i role play as much as i can. i have found its great for practicing my own writing as it forces me to leave my imagination open; specially as you can't really predict how the other rp'ers will move the story along. i choose menewsha for this merely because this site has such good rp'ers.

Quote:

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
even if they didnt earn gold for posting on a 18+ site im sure, many rp'ers would enjoy a place that they didnt have to hide and break up the story line in incidents that entail a 18+ scene. not to mention itll help many people want to join the site.

Quote:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
as so many other people have said a delete button. itll make it much easier to erase those awkward posts, or posts that just was a mistake.

Quote:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
as to paying mennies for? not that i can think of.

leasfy 07-19-2010 02:58 AM

Why do you roleplay?
The ability to create a world that is controlled by me and my RP Partner attracts me. I don't need to be an actor to play as someone else.

Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
This is actually the website which I learned how to be an RPer. It's easier to find a partner since no noob I have encountered so far...

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?

My thought? it'd be this - -" Lemme use my wild imagination!!!:illgetu:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
Guild!

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
Instead of having an 18+ section, it'd be nicer to have a guild feature so that only the guild member that can view the content with the exception of mods of course. And every time a subforum is made, instead of requiring gold, the owner shall pay it with mennies. That way the owner of the guild will use the guild wisely. :yes:

Also, for the private roleplay section, it might be a good idea to create a feature to hide the content of their thread from others. This feature will only allow those who are tagged only can view it. And of course staffs can still see it to ensure posters abide the rules of Menewsha.


If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?

I don't RP on other site :no:

Cap'n Kidd 07-19-2010 03:17 AM

I love roleplaying because it's a way to escape the shit that is my life and be another person for a play. Different worlds, different races..

I think that an 18+ section would be nice -- but how do you know the people roleplaying in it are 18+? IMVU, for instance, has a feature where you prove your age with, well, proof, like a drivers license. Maybe something like that could be implemented, but that would also mean there'd be more work to do.

Marsyas 07-19-2010 03:30 AM

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
I roleplay because it gives me a chance to exercise all this excess imagination I seem to have roaming around in the cranium. It also provides me with an escape, as I'm sure it does for most of us, but it does allow me to reflect on myself on certain personal levels while helping keep me sane on some days.

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
I think an 18+ section would be beneficial even though I would only use it sparingly. It would provide the outting needed for those moments in a rp when there are more mature things going on, so I'm all for it.

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
Maybe an option to use a specific font as a default rather than having to go advanced every time to change the font. Usless there's already one and I can't find it :sweat:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
Honestly... No, not really.

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?
Menewsha was the first site I joined like this and I don't like any other site as much as this so I've got nothing to say here...

PaintTheSkyRed 07-19-2010 03:35 AM

I like to roleplay because I am a writer and this way it gives me practice while working with other people. I use to roleplay years ago addictively but I quit and I didn't find anywhere else I liked besides an old site I was on. When I found Menewsha is RP-love-at-first-site. I like the way the forums are set up and it is very helpful for the OOC forums. I tend to feel iffy about the PG-13 restriction. I tend to RP doing yaoi and that restriction comes in to play so things don't get taken too far. Which is a pain to skip around things but at the same I understand the need for because of the younger crowd here.

I wouldn't mind there being an 18+ area but there could be problems with that. Like for instance younger crowd reading the RPs on the Spy or just lurking in the section like little curious people they are. Would there be able to be a age blockage section? Like they try to get into the area and it would block it if they aren't 18? But at the same time if that happens then you will be getting 13 years old making accounts as 18 years to get around that. When you post you can it on the SPy so maybe the opition where it won't show up there? So it is a good or bad thing to have. Even though I do like getting gold I understand that not getting gold could be a benefit. RPers won't spend as much time in the section where they won't get gold for it unless it is a good roleplay. I still think if there is an 18+ section that there should be seperate forums for each like schools, & etc.

I would like the opition to delete posts but it doesn't bother me too much. And for the things worth paying for. Maybe every time you make a thread you donate a dollar? It would take away the clutter of so many forums and it would show who truely wants to pay for their pleasure of RPing in that section or not. Or if maybe if you want to join the 18+ crowd you pay 5 dollars once a year? I would rather not to pay but I understand the fianical need for it.

And the old site I roleplayed on was all in IM way. It was easier that you can post in two different ways. You posted in regular IM way and then you can post in an action way for the roleplay. It would pop up on either side of your post reading '**ACTION**' which made me laugh since that is slightly like a movie. It did not have Ads. It was mostly word of mouth. You could block certain people, so the ignore button was my best friend, but besides that it was the company I kept that pleased me about the site. But I have even better company here.

Ember Mist 07-19-2010 03:41 AM

OMG an 18+ forum would be awesome...
and it could cost mene's to gain access too...
I would totally love that^^
Maybe 3 mene's for access..

I roleplay on Crysandrea.com, but they do not have 18+ forums..
Adultadventurers.com is another good site. that one is strictly 18+.
but I do like to Earn gold for my roleplays..
so perhaps have maybe two certain mods just for that forum to make sure no one is breaking the rules?

Miley Cyrus 07-19-2010 04:01 AM

Quote:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
because it is an escape from reality, and i need it...
i use menewsha because it is friendly and safe.


Quote:

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
i think that the PG-13 section is good, as the roleplays don't get out of hand.
I think that an 18+ section would be a great idea for people who like to get...down and dirty.


Quote:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?
a delete button, seriously, an edit button is a good idea, but if you posted it in the wrong forum, it gets hard editing them quickly before people read it.


Quote:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
having an active roleplay for 6 months? because thats really hard. and by active i mean like 2-4 posts a day, minimum.

Xai 07-19-2010 04:06 AM

I roleplay because I love to write. Sometimes it's nice to form stories with someone else instead of doing it by yourself. As for why I roleplay here: that's because the roleplay I really enjoy working on is on here. xD

I can understand why the restriction is there, but it can be really frustrating at times. An 18+ rp section would be LOVELY. That way if things in our roleplays get a little mature, we can just do a few posts in the 18+ section before moving back to the regular 13+ section.

Evermore_112 07-19-2010 05:09 AM

18+
I wanna delete my posts.
And omgosh can we PLEASE double post. Setting up a roleplay is HELL without double posting.

Wulfwynn 07-19-2010 06:09 AM

I roleplay to help pass the time at work plus it forces me to become more creative. I've RP'd a bit before I came to mene but not much. Though RPing here has helped me go from no-lit to semi-lit. XD

I've got mixed feeling about an 18+ section. I think it would be good if you needed a place for some gruesome violence or if your rp became more "mature" but at the same time how would we make sure it stays 18+? Plus like it was stated before I don't want mene to become a place for people to go just to cyber.

Emma Corrin 07-19-2010 06:15 AM

Quote:

Why do you roleplay? Why do you choose Menewsha for this?
I roleplay because it is truly the only way that I can feed my artistic side and be happy with it. I write because I cannot write the novel I desire. I roleplay because it passes the time, it allows me to be creative, and it allows me to escape into a whole new world just like a novel does; only this time I'm creating it with my roleplay partners.

I choose Menewsha for my roleplays because of their rules. The rules and regulations set by Menewsha allow for my creativity to prosper. Grant it, in some ways it's limiting, but for the vast majority it is truly the greatest place to roleplay because it allows so many things and is truly a PG 13 roleplaying community. I have tried roleplaying on other sites and it just doesn't seem to work out - their rules are far too limiting and not as allowing as Menewsha's. Menewsha is truly the only place that allows my creativity to roam free.


Quote:

What are your thoughts on the current PG-13 restriction? If there was an 18+ section that didn't earn gold so the mods didn't have to read it would you be interested in it?
The current PG 13 restrictions are wonderful. They're a tad bit limiting for romance, but they're over all very allowing and are easy to follow by. However, I would like to see the 18+ section implemented for such romantic scenes. Now, I'm not talking full blown descriptions of sex or what have you, but it would just be a tad easier to roleplay the romantic bits without fearing it's overstepping a PG 13 atmosphere in general, if you know what I mean.
Quote:

What features would you like to see to make your roleplays easier/better?

I honestly think our roleplaying community is fine the way it is. I think maybe a way to have a profile inserted into a post in the thread for the characters that you can fill in (ex. upload a photo and fill in information about like height, weight, eye color, hair color, piercings, etc.) would be a nice feature - but it'd be rather time consuming to create, I would think.

Quote:

Can you think of anything that would be worth paying mennies for?
Not particularly. Perhaps a one time small purchase for the aforementioned profile idea, but other than that I don't really see anything that would require mennies to be purchased. Also, if the profile idea were to be taken into consideration and you were thinking of having mennies used as a way to gain access to such a feature, I think anything more than $.50, or even more than a $1 if it were long, would a waste. I mean, I'd pay a one time fee of $.50 for a premade fill-in profile or a one time fee of $1 for a long profile where you can fill in/add and take a way categories, per OC of course, but I wouldn't pay more than that.

Quote:

If you roleplay on other sites, what do they offer that you like? If you answer this, please elaborate your answer for me. Are those sites monetized by anything other than ads?
There's honestly nothing in particular I like about the sites. I didn't stay on them long enough to really roleplay. Their rules are similar to Menewsha's from what I remember, however.
The other sites I have been on are monetized, if I am reading this correctly, only by MCs and ads to my knowledge. These sites would include ernya.com and celainia.com.
I have roleplayed on gaiaonline.com, but it wasn't much and it was a longgg time ago. I quit roleplaying there because people were randomly posting in the threads and spamming just for the heck of it and I got fed up with it.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:31 PM.