This Rough Magic: A Game of Songs
 

Three things that make me smile are words, music, and games.

And, so: A game of songs, lyrics, and mysteries...

THE RULES

The game is simple:

The person running the round posts a list of songs, all of which have a shared theme but one. This theme or shared element could be within the lyrics, within the music, or something about the history of the songs. The players guess what the theme is, and which song is the odd one out.


Here are the rest of the details:

Rounds:
- Songs can be posted as titles only (artist optional, no other details)
- Each round will have at least four song titles, and no more than eight
- All songs must be available on SoundCloud or Grooveshark
- The theme must be discoverable through listening or research-- It cannot not be something specific to the submitter like "I listened to them all on my birthday" but it can be somewhat open to interpretation.
- The winner of the previous round may post a new round. (They should coordinate with me, so the post gets edited.)
- I will submit the first round, and by default any others.
- New rounds will be in the first post, plus as a new post.


Guessing:
- You are encouraged to listen to the songs (unless you already know them) before guessing.
- No referring to transcribed song lyrics. (You can use the internet to look up history and theories about songs.)
- A guess consists of one theme answer and one odd song out answer. (Both, and only one of each.)
- You may not guess again unless someone else has guessed in between.
- Please put the word GUESS in bold and red in your post so I can see them easily.
- You are encouraged to post links (SoundCloud or Grooveshark) to the songs, in your guess.
- If you win a round, you may post the next round. (Otherwise, I will.)

Winning:
- The same person cannot win two rounds in a row.
- You can collect a prize after one win, or save up for a bigger price.
- ONE WIN: 100 gold
- TWO WINS: 250 gold
- FIVE WINS: Currently available CI


TLDR:
- A round is a list of song titles
- Guess the theme they share, and the odd one out that doesn't
- Include "GUESS" in your answer
- Each player can only guess once per page
- You also need to wait for someone else to guess before you can guess again
- Don't look up the lyrics
- Win stuff!

EXAMPLE ROUND

Round Posting:
Successful Answer:
PAST ROUNDS:
(Coming after the first round...)

(Reserving this post for anything I forget to reserve another one for.)

FIRST ROUND:
Ana Ng
If You Want Me to Stay
Money for Nothing
Rock and Roll Suicide
The Sickbed of Cuchulainn
We Are the Champions

interesting game we have here Tam

Thanks. I hope people like it. I was trying to come up with a game that could work on a forum, but wasn't all about text.

I'll give it a shot on my next work break.

I wonder if Seridano:, dessertdesiert:, Vox:, Queen_Andais:, hummy: or any of our other playmates from past games might enjoy this one?

---------- Post added 06-11-2013 at 02:51 PM ----------

(Ooops. Pinged Seri a little too late.)

lol <w< i'll ping some people if ya want

You'd be welcome to! I'd love for people who like games to see this thread, in case any of them are interested. (Game threads seem to be my favorite part of Mene, so I thought I should host one myself.)

Ikuto Akihiko Hasegawa: Veno: `Kitami: woohoohelloppl:

o3o come check out this game Tam is doing

*pokes Ikuto*

Sadly, it looks like pings/mentions are broken right now.

Oh, good-- Glad you made your way here! (I got a ping with a broken link, and so did someone else. So I think they aren't all working.)

Oooh, Queenie's here!

It looks like the game may be starting to gain some momentum. We have had quite a few visitors, and I know at least one person is checking out the songs. I hope I didn't make this round too hard!

Oh wow. This is going to require some research. Let's see if I can figure this one out...

/cheers Vox on

Well, nothing from Wikipedia so far, haha. I'll have to wait until later to try actually listening to the songs. I've actually never heard of Ana Ng or The Sickbed of Cuchulainn.

And I have a feeling about which one is the odd song out... but I'll wait until I have more evidence to make a guess. Do we have infinite guesses?

The rules explain more about guessing. You do have infinite guesses, but you can only guess once per page-- and you can't guess again unless someone else has guessed in between. (I may tweak that for the next round depending on how this goes, though.)

Also remember that you're supposed to guess the odd one out and the theme the other share, at the same time. (Otherwise people could just guess each song one at a time, and work out the theme from there.)

I have made some changed to the rules, to streamline the game.

1.) Listening to the songs is encouraged, and will usually help get the answer, but it's not required.

2.) You no longer need to wait for a new page to guess again. (Just for someone else to guess.)

Eh, but if listening is not required, does that mean we can't hide the uniting theme in the tone/lyrics/etc?

I am terrible with songs, and what are those sites that you listed to listen to them on?