I was a HUGE fan of the first one. If fandom could be measured in height, I'd be the Colossus of Rhodes. It was even better that I had went expecting it to suck and came out awed. I walked around randomly doing a Jack swagger and eyes for a week (mostly to annoy a friend, who finally admitted that yes, he liked the movie and yes, I did a pretty damn good imitation).

The second one was pretty good, but they were trying to out-do the first too much that it got bloated. Still, the payoff in At World's End should be interesting. I still refuse to believe Davy Jones was fully CGI. Why couldn't George Lucas make his crap look that good?