Originally Posted by Youn

I have some question on this; after forgetting my past, would I be able to remember that I had made that desicion?
Somehow, I think not being able to remember that I had chosen to forget would make me obsessed with trying to remember?

Also, just what kind of memories would disappear? Everything, and I mean everything, you've ever known (including basic skills like walking, eating and speech) or more of the "photo album" sort of memories ("Ah yes, this is where I went to high shool. And you're my sister!") ?

That said, if I had to choose, it'd be forgetting my past. As difficult as that would be, I think I would be able to move on from that. In a way, sort of like a victim of a stroke or car accident might have to re-learn what abilities and memories they had lost in the accident.
The thought of not being able to make any new memories is just too sad to me. I don't think I'd see any real point in even trying as I wouldn't be able to remember it anyway. There just would not be any point of trying to progress if you kept ending up back at square one. Constant status quo is, outside of TV shows, a pretty depressing state to be in I think.

Also, I sort of see forgetting your past as a one-time thing, something you'd be able to fix in time and move on from (i.e. this is where I started to make new memories). With not being able to make any new memories it'll be something that'd happen to you every day, every hour, every time you every did anything.

Or wait, did you mean to continue to forget your past memories as you go along? Because then I wouldn't know what to choose. D: