I saw All Stars Battle Royal at E3 I don't think it looks very good in my opinion :/ Maybe it's slightly different, it was a few months ago since I saw anything to do with it. I've never owned an Xbox but Forza Horizon would be the reason that I would get one, my first console was a PS3 I got it when it first came out, and I still have the same one, a 60GB Super Fat one xD