My girlfriend has dragged me kicking and screaming down the world of organic cosmetics, haha. Though I'm not complaining--I've never looked better!
For my soap and lotion needs, I generally shop at
Be Natural Organics. Their stuff is pricey, but the ingredients are all pretty solid and they have great stuff for problem skin like mine.
I haven't really found any shampoo or conditioner that I really like that's also organic, but
Sante has some good stuff (though even with Amazon, I have the hardest time getting a hold of their products.) I'm trying out another brand of shampoo and conditioner try now, and it makes my hair soooo stiff and dry. Ugh. I see some wonderful suggestions in this thread, though, so I'm totally going to give them a shot!
Make-up-wise... I'm totally horrible and still using products with bad ingredients.

But I wear make up waaaaaay less then I did before I made the change, so, progress?