Which Avatar Do You Prefer & Why?

What to Do:

• Look at the two avatars above you.
• Pick the one you like more.
• Post a specific reason WHY you picked that avatar. Please make it as CONSTRUCTIVE as possible. Offer suggestions if you have them! ACers appreciate a good critique.

Rules:
1) Obey the TOS and Menewsha's Rules.
2) Your post must include WHY you chose the avatar. Simply saying "I like Edward's avatar" or "Melly's is awesome" are not enough. Please honor the spirit of the thread: constructive criticism and praise for great avatars!
3) Don't sandwich post! (ex. I post, User posts, I post again) This means you can never choose yourself.
4) Be considerate! Be sure to give constructive criticism.
5) Be sure to post a "Skip Me" note in your post if you're not choosing between two avatars, and just commenting on something.

Updated 8/7/13: Clarified the "why" requirement and removed broken images. -Belly