Thread Tools

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#1
Old 12-06-2008, 08:58 PM

GRACIOUS 2008 JUDGING

PLEASE READ CAREFULLY!

First off, HOSTS ONLY.

Alrighty, so here is how we are going to do it.

First, I will need to contact all of the hosts and get a list of entries for each of the categories involved.

Then I will post the entries per category in this thread.

Then each of the hosts and myself will score each entry of every category and contest on a 1-10 basis.

The person in each category that gets the highest collective score is the winner of that category.


Understand?


Reserving posts still.

Last edited by Burnt Biscuits; 12-15-2008 at 01:28 AM..

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#2
Old 12-15-2008, 01:33 AM

HOW TO JUDGE


Go through and for every entry, fill out this form:


Entrant: (username)
Contest:
Catagory:
Score:
Commentary: (optional)


Keep them grouped together by contest and category, scores MUST be whole numbers such as 2, 6, 9, 10, ect. 8.5 is not acceptable.

Please note the art and av contests each have two separate categories in need of scoring.

Be careful not to miss an entry, as doing so lowers the person's score unfairly.

Please have this done by the 25th, and no later.


On accurate completion of the judging you will be sen a little present as a thank you for all your effort. <3

Last edited by Burnt Biscuits; 01-08-2009 at 04:53 AM..

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#3
Old 12-15-2008, 01:48 AM

ENTRIES:

WRITING CONTEST

Quote:
Originally Posted by Winterwolfgoddess
PLEASE READ THE FOLLOWING LINK WHEN JUDGING TO PROPERLY SCORE THESE LITERARY WORKS ON A 1-10 SCALE: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4265593-post4.html

Username of entrant: ArrogantSoul
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4279833-post36.html
Category: N/A
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: xlightwingx
Link to submission: http://www.fictionpress.com/s/2600187/1/Chain_of_Gold
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: woopdidoodoo
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4293240-post91.html
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: swanniee
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4312009-post123.html
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Pearl
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4314582-post131.html
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Ethereal Lullaby
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4317790-post133.html
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Rylynne
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4318024-post135.html
Category:
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Lumi
Link to submission: http://www.menewsha.com/forum/4318272-post140.html
Category:
Comments or details:

ART CONTEST
Quote:
Originally Posted by linapoo
Art Contest

Username of entrant: Celestial Pocky
Link to submission:
http://i34.tinypic.com/2r41ic7.png
Category: CG
Comments or details: None

Username of entrant: Eserel
Link to submission:
x
Category: CG
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Eserel
Link to submission:
x
Category: CG
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Eserel
Link to submission:
x
Category: CG
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Lumi
Link to submission:
http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y30/m-c/tgt_knerd.jpg
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Kultura
Link to submission:
Linky Linky Link!
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: `F o a m
Link to submission:
http://i38.tinypic.com/znndk9.png
Category: CG
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: blueblackrose
Link to submission:
http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e1...yumehfinal.png
Category: CG
Comments or details: "Iro is search for Yumeh and ends up trailing him into the graveyard. Was is coincidence or did Yumeh lead him there on purpose?" -blueblackrose

Username of entrant: Karayna
Link to submission:
Linkeh
Category: Traditional
Comments or details: Total time was 4~5 hours over an 8 day period.

Username of entrant: `F o a m
Link to submission:
http://i36.tinypic.com/seva01.png
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Thoth Star
Link to submission:
art
Category: CG
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: Lura Crane
Link to submission:
http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j3..._LuraCrane.png
Category: Traditional
Comments or details: Inked with Mircon pen, colored with watercolor pencils, and waterbrush.

Username of entrant: Lumi
Link to submission:
http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y30/m-c/tgt_ck.jpg
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: .Simplicity.
Link to submission:
Clicky~
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:

Username of entrant: .Simplicity.
Link to submission:
Clicky~
Category: Traditional
Comments or details:


Username of entrant: Ceridwen_Crystaline Ikoda
Link to submission:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v6...ellycgcopy.png
Full Resolution:
http://www.yourfavoritewebsite.com/images/jellycg.png
Category: CG
Comments or details: She tried to make the skin super refined (she didn't have much time though.) And unfinished but 'artistic' in contrast.

Some forms where the same thing, so I left them out. If I missed any, tell me? C:


Quote:
Originally Posted by `Kitami


Hobo-Fabulous



I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: [L]ove[H]ate
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Mingnon
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Ethereal Lullaby
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Risque
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Ferra
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username:MacSen191
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Winter Wind
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Kiari
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: FlyingYume1
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username:Paprika
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Thoth Star
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Sakura_Madison
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Luenola Marxiel
Your entry:


I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Knerd
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: ox3tyi
Your entry:


I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Rylynne
Your entry:


I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: nvs
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!b
Username: PlatinumChild
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Pixore
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Yeah
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Kultura
Your entry:


I'm so bad... it's good!
Username:blueblackrose
Your entry:

I'm so bad... it's good!
Username:Zodioniac
Your entry:


I'm so bad... it's good!
Username: Lumi
Your entry:




Color Me Themed

I can't be ugly!
Username: juniper_silver
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Knerd
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: [L]ove[H]ate
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Pixore
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Risque
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Lumi
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Mingnon
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Winter Wind
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Kiari
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: LillieRose
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username:Paprika
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: ox3tyi
Your entry:


I can't be ugly!
Username: Sakura_Madison
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Thoth Star
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username:PlatinumChild
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: nvs
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Kultura
Your entry:


I can't be ugly!
Username:blueblackrose
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Zodioniac
Your entry:


I can't be ugly!
Username: Ethereal Lullaby
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Rylynne
Your entry:


I can't be ugly!
Username: Iroase Delschatten
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Luenola Marxiel
Your entry:

I can't be ugly!
Username: Majhra


I can't be ugly!
Username: Sizzla
Your entry:




CHARITABLE MENEWSHIAN: Swanniee is our winner. n.n

ART EXCHANGE: Ererel is our winner with 11 freebie arts of lovely quality.

Last edited by Burnt Biscuits; 01-07-2009 at 06:58 PM..

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#4
Old 01-09-2009, 08:30 AM

HOSTS



That's right, I'm putting the list of judges and completed judging here to encourage people to hurry up and get it done. I would like all judging forms posted here by the 25th at the very latest.


INCOMPLETE. >[

Burnt Biscuits
WinterWolfGoddess
[L]ove[H[ate
Stormy1
Cherry Flavored Antacid
Zombie Pixie
Queen Demon
Kitkat
Linapoo
Iroase Delchatten (Only if you have the time. ;D )
'Kitami
Tilly
Enzeru



COMPLETED. :]

Cherry Who?
Spooky Scary Skeleton
11591.83
Cherry Who? is offline
 
#5
Old 01-09-2009, 06:17 PM

Two of the avatars for the contest aren't displaying. Should I PM them? Or are they just disqualified?

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#6
Old 01-10-2009, 01:48 AM

This thread should be for judging forms only, I'd prefer questioned pmed to TGT. n.n

But yeah, I'd say pm them, but it's kinda their own fault for not properly hosting the image/continuing to do so, so I can't feel too bad for them. Go ahead and send the a pm, but we aren't going to be responsible if they get it to us after someone's already judged their lack of avie.

Winterwolfgoddess
Miss You Guys
Penpal
12125.20
Winterwolfgoddess is offline
 
#7
Old 01-10-2009, 02:39 AM

WRITING CONTEST
Quote:
Entrant: Arrogant Soul
Contest: above
Catagory: WC
Score: 6

Entrant: xlightwingx
Contest: WC
Catagory: n/a
Score: 9

Entrant: woopdidoodoo
Contest: WC
Catagory: n/a
Score: 8

Entrant: swanniee
Contest: WC
Catagory: na
Score: 8

Entrant: pearl
Contest: wc
Catagory: na
Score: 10

Entrant: Ethereal lullaby
Contest: wc
Catagory: na
Score: 9

Entrant: Rylynne
Contest: wc
Catagory: na
Score: 9

Entrant: Lumi
Contest: wc
Catagory: na
Score: 7
ART CONTEST
Quote:
Username of entrant: Celestial Pocky
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 9

Username of entrant: Eserel
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 6

Username of entrant: Eserel
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 6

Username of entrant: Eserel
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 7

Username of entrant: `F o a m
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 5

Username of entrant: blueblackrose
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 7

Username of entrant: Thoth Star
Contest: art
Category: CG
Score: 5

Username of entrant: Ceridwen_Crystaline Ikoda
Contest: Art
Category: CG
Score: 8

Username of entrant: Lumi
Contest: art
Category: Traditional
Score: 5

Username of entrant: Kultura
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score: 8

Username of entrant: Karayna
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score: 10

Username of entrant: `F o a m
Contest: art
Category: Traditional
Score: 4

Username of entrant: Lura Crane
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score: 9

Username of entrant: Lumi
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score: ??
Comment: Isn't traditional hand drawn. this looks computer drawn

Username of entrant: .Simplicity.
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score: 6

Username of entrant: .Simplicity.
Contest: Art
Category: Traditional
Score:5
Avatar Contest
Quote:
Entrant: [L]ove[H]ate
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 3

Entrant: Mingnon
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 5

Entrant: Ethereal Lullaby
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Risque
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 6

Entrant: Ferra
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 6

Entrant: MacSen191
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Winter Wind
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Kiari
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 3

Entrant: FlyingYume1
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Paprika
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 5

Entrant: Thoth Star
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Sakura_Madison
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Luenola Marxiel
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 5

Entrant: Knerd
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 6

Entrant: ox3tyi
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 7

Entrant: Rylynne
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 9

Entrant: nvs
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: PlatinumChild
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 3

Entrant: Pixore
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 6

Entrant: Yeah
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 3

Entrant: Kultura
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: blueblackrose
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 4

Entrant: Zodioniac
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 5

Entrant: Lumi
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Hobo-fab
Score: 0
Comment: Avatar not viewable


Entrant: juniper_silver
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: Knerd
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 9

Entrant: [L]ove[H]ate
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 4

Entrant: Pixore
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: Risque
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: Lumi
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 7

Entrant: Mingnon
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 4

Entrant: Winter Wind
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: Kiari
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: LillieRose
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: Paprika
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 8

Entrant: ox3tyi
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 0
Comment: Avatar cannot be accessed

Entrant: Sakura_Madison
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 7

Entrant: Thoth Star
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 3

Entrant: PlatinumChild
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: nvs
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 4

Entrant: Kultura
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: blueblackrose
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: Zodioniac
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 6

Entrant: Ethereal Lullaby
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 7

Entrant: Rylynne
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 8

Entrant: Iroase Delschatten
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: Luenola Marxiel
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 5

Entrant: Majhra
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 7

Entrant: Sizzla
Contest: Avatar
Catagory: Color-Me-Themed
Score: 9

Last edited by Winterwolfgoddess; 01-10-2009 at 03:32 AM..

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#8
Old 01-10-2009, 02:43 AM

Winter, judged are required to judge all categories, please do so and edit the other judgings into your post?

Winterwolfgoddess
Miss You Guys
Penpal
12125.20
Winterwolfgoddess is offline
 
#9
Old 01-10-2009, 03:01 AM

xD That is what I am doing bisbis.
I am adding a category each time once I complete it so I won't get overwhelmed. :lol:

Burnt Biscuits
(◎_◎;)
Banned
53.45
Burnt Biscuits is offline
 
#10
Old 01-10-2009, 03:16 AM

Alrighty, just wanted to be sure you knew. <3

The Giving Tree
⊙ω⊙
Banned
6.36
The Giving Tree is offline
 
#11
Old 01-23-2009, 08:18 PM

Guys, I really need those forms in.


NOTICE!

If you are unable to post here, PM THE FORM TO ME.

Last edited by The Giving Tree; 01-23-2009 at 08:47 PM..

 


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

 
Forum Jump

no new posts