10-05-2012, 04:50 AM
I have heard of these, there was a really big scandal about them for quite awhile and I'm not entirely sure if it's died down yet or not. He made a pretty wonderful website for the books though, and I did attempt to give them a read, but after awhile I had to stop. It was very clear that he was very much an American who didn't have a full understanding of British culture, and the inclusion of so much American themes turned me away from the series rather quickly.
Part of what makes Harry Potter so special to me has always been the fact that its very British. I've read scads of fanfiction as a result of the series, and nothing causes me to leave quicker than the inclusion of Mary Sues, or the Americanizing of the stories. I'm not saying this gentleman isn't a good writer; he definitely has a strong grasp of story weaving. Ultimately though, his works are fanfiction (Fanfiction he was making money off of, for a time, thus the lawsuit/scandal/etc) and part of the fandom is the fact Harry Potter is a British story, so I for one was not at all a fan. That said, the Americanizing appeals to American markets, so he's certainly done well in the aspect of causing yet more youth to connect to the tales, so props for that I suppose.
|