Good: It's very big and definitely gets "long cat" across

Harsh: I would like to see some more of that red around the middle of your avatar

Positive: Your avi looks really cute and nicely balanced color wise
Negative: I wish the gold flowers matched the other gold items

Good: It's cute and spring like.

Harsh: The color of the hair bugs me no end. I think it might be because you have the black on the second layer. Maybe try making the second layer a dark brown.

Good: Very regal and cool without getting overcomplicated and jumble-y. Your avatar almost looks like she ought to be the queen of the leprechauns.

Harsh: It would benefit so much with something white near your feet. As it is, the white is about equal with gold and I'm assuming you're only trying to have gold accents by the way you chose not to wear golden feathers or gloves. Another solution might be swapping the white for gold, but that might make everything look a little too simple...

Good: The theme flows very well and the colors fit nicely.

Harsh: I think the orange.. stuff, at the bottom is a bit much and throws the balance way off.

Good: Very awesome and deadly looking.

Harsh: They border thing doesn't really go for me, but it does make it look like a portrait which is awesome.

Good - It's really lovely and a very nice Spring/Easter/May Day avatar.

Harsh - It feels a little cluttered on the avatar's right side.

Positive: I absolutely love the winter samurai theme of this!
Negative: I am not liking the eye colour you chose on her. I'd think a blue, grey, or red eye colour would look better. Besides that, it is simply awesome!

Good: I love the use of items I don't get to see too often. Not to mention the monochrome look of this. I always appreciate a good monochrome-ish Avi^^

Harsh: To me, the body of your avi just blends together. Its where my eye is first drawn.

postive: It's a great start and what yo have goes well together.

negative: You need a bit more in your background. I think the green background of Dryad's Hallow would look stunning and bring out the green in your clothing.

Positive~ I love the coloring and the vibe I'm getting off of it.

Negative~ Maybe change the eyes? Though I love them, I keep getting distracted by them. >.<

Positive: Awesome theme, I love everything about it! The colors, the background~

Negative: Perhaps put some purple on the legs? Or somewhere on the lower part of the body!

Good: I love the simplicity of this avatar.

Harsh: I'm not sure if its possible, but I wonder if your hair could be made to be more of a harsh black and white.

Good: I love the colors and the overall theme of your avi!

Harsh: Trying and find an item that could go near her feet? Maybe grass? An animal? Something!

Good: Just amazing. Just love it. Great layering. Great colors. Great theme.

Harsh: Nothing comes to mind.

Pro: Looks really well done and classy.
Con: Can't think of a thing.

The colors are great together!
but there's not much layering going on (not that that is a bad thing :) )

love the over all theme
but I don't like the random bits of light.

Great avatar. Can't really think of anything bad.

Great avatar. Can't think of a thing to criticize.

Positive~ The theme and colors are awesome! ^-^

Negative~ I think the dark trees are a bit out of place.

Positive: This avatar is really delightful. Not only did you successfully create a scene, but a character that works within that scene as well. It's obvious you really thought about what you chose to include and where you were placing everything and it looks great for it!

Negative: You really need some lavender on the left side of your avatar somehow... perhaps as an eye color? It just doesn't feel absolutely color balanced as it is right now.

Postive: Just love it. Love the use of the wings and the colors work well together.

Negative: Nothing for me.

Positive: I love the Theme!

Negative: I can't really think of anything...

Good: I love that theme you have. It's nice.
Bad: He has black eyes! Poor fella..